Verbing a search engine

Classic spiderweb attached to a flowering plant

I don’t Google much anymore, having set DuckDuckGo as my default search engine on every device and browser that I use routinely. I do struggle slightly with finding a good verb to use for it, though. Google has managed to embed itself in our language as both a business and as a daily activity, and I have to applaud them for that. I started using Google in the late 1990s, when it was a young upstart, and I readily admit they have (and have long had) a very solid search engine. It was fast and streamlined from my first use, and has long had a more intuitive interface than its predecessors. Several years ago, though, as I became more aware of the growth of privacy concerns, I heard of a newer, privacy-oriented search engine and I decided to try DuckDuckGo. As a happy Google user, I expected to have to make a trade-off between privacy and user experience. I was delighted and surprised by the reality. I find DuckDuckGo every bit as intuitive and effective as its top competitor. It offers a visually clean interface, solid and expansive results, and clear identification of advertisements among those results. In general, I tend to find its results a better fit for my searches and less dominated by the tricky ads that make you believe they are official websites for a known organization. In library work, I have seen many of those types of advertisements lure desperate patrons into questionable portals for drivers licenses and birth certificates, paywall versions of telephone listings, and expensive resume services that looked to be free, among others.

Since both search engines satisfy my essential needs of finding and presenting relevant and accurate results reliably and quickly, I can use privacy considerations as another standard criterion, rather than a luxury add-on. In that category, DuckDuckGo is a clear winner. Privacy is a primary goal of the search engine, and they have an entire section of their website to discuss it and promote more private ways to use the internet, in addition to providing browser extensions and apps for mobile devices. (https://duckduckgo.com/about) They emphasize that the company does not track user search history, nor collect personal information. Since they do not collect or store the information, it is not available to be hacked, sold, or collected by subpoena. This may result in less personalized results and ads, but I regard that as a feature rather than a drawback. I would prefer to choose results from a larger and less-tailored group than see only a pre-filtered list that may omit or bury a result. I also find DuckDuckGo’s predictive text suggestions quite reliable without a need to connect them to my previous searches.

Since they do not sell user information, a logical question is how the search engine produces revenue to operate. DuckDuckGo sells ads on its platform, which is a common revenue model. Unlike Google and many other platforms, DuckDuckGo does not target those advertisements based on a user’s prior searches. Ads shown are based solely on the search terms entered at the time. This can provide a more comprehensive results list and will not advantage some brands over others based on your history with them. (Sheth) DuckDuckGo also earns a small commission from affiliate partnerships with companies like eBay and Amazon, when users follow links from their searches to purchase items from these sellers. Finally, DuckDuckGo also earns a very small portion of its income by licensing commercial users to access its “Tracker Radar” system. This system is freely accessible by the public to see common methods being used to follow internet users with publicly available information, but can be used commercially for a fee to DuckDuckGo.

If you are concerned about your online privacy or just interested in learning more about a different way to search, I encourage you to check out duckduckgo.com, and consider using it as your default browser!

References

  • Duckduckgo homepage. (n.d) DuckDuckGo. Retrieved October 29, 2022 from https://duckduckgo.com/about.
  • Sheth, N. (2022, August 18). How does duckduckgo make money? Finty. https://finty.com/us/business-models/duckduckgo/

Who’s Pulling Your Strings?

My fourth grade teacher was a novel experience for me in a lot of ways. He was my first male teacher and my first teacher to assign long-term projects. He taught a group of us to play guitar after school. As a first-year teacher assembling a classroom library from whatever he had at home that was remotely suitable for elementary students, he introduced me to several series and characters that I would otherwise not have met that early. (Thank you, Mr. Haas, for my enduring love of The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy and Get Smart!) He helped our class write and compose two songs, and then record them in an actual studio. I presume that somewhere during that year, we covered the expected academic topics, as well, as we all seemed to be ready for fifth grade the following year.

"Are You Being Watched?" Sign
Sign at tiger exhibit, Denver Zoo

One of his most lasting impacts on my thought patterns was the unit we did on advertising. We looked at various strategies used for selling, including both what they looked like and why they worked. We were sent home to find examples of each and describe the components of the ads. I can’t say advertising doesn’t work on me, but I can say that I tend to notice and attempt to deconstruct its methods and goals more often than some folks I observe.  That unit was what caused a flash of recognition in me for Tristan Harris’ line, “what we don’t talk about is how the handful of people working at a handful of technology companies through their choices will steer what a billion people are thinking today.” (Harris, 2017) There are plenty of methods of advertising, and the internet is not the only outlet. It’s just one of the most potent and omnipresent. With a relatively small number of individuals at the helm and making many of the decisions about what we see, how we see it, and whose viewpoints get heard, it’s still a good idea to have some idea about how our experience on the internet is curated and shaped before we even encounter it.  As I investigated the question, I encountered a 2015 multi-part report from MIT Technology Review, entitled “Persuasive Technology.”  It was their May/June 2015 Business Report section. In an article entitled “Technology and Persuasion,” (Byrnes, 2015,) the researcher describes methods to keep people hooked on a particular game by recognizing behaviors that might mean they are getting bored and responding to those, or how a corporate wellness provider group uses data and game designers to maintain engagement from the workforce at a higher level than previously achieved. The researcher also cited an ad firm’s use of tracking data to better choose more effective advertising for individual users. Another article entitled, “New Technologies Persuade in Old Ways,” (Anders, 2015) specifically called out some of the strategies that have been used in some form to guide people’s behavior since times long before the internet was a consideration. Anders described these strategies as: “reciprocity, likeability, authority, scarcity, consistency, and social proof.”(Anders, 2015) If you think about those for a few minutes, you will readily see them at work all around you. Most of us would rather buy from or participate with a company that we see as friendly to us and/or our causes. We like to follow people’s feeds that may respond to us and boost our profile. We readily follow other users’ or experts’ advice and reviews on products and services, and items that sell out or advertise a limited number of opportunities are catering to our need for things that we see as limited.

If you’re interested in how companies may be programming you, take a look at one of these articles, or some of the others in the edition. They all seem to be short and easily digested. What did you learn, and how will it affect your outlook or behavior moving forward?

Anders, G. (2015, March 23). New technologies persuade in old ways. MIT Technology Review, Volume 110, No. 3. Retrieved from: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/535831/new-technologies-persuade-in-old-ways/?set=535816.  

Byrnes, N. (2015, March 23). Technology and persuasion. MIT Technology Review, Volume 110, No. 3. Retrieved from: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/535826/technology-and-persuasion/?set=535816.  

TED. (2017, July 28). How a handful of tech companies control billions of minds every day | Tristan Harris. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C74amJRp730.

Spiders, the web, and me

Spider on the ceiling in the corner

I am pretty phobic about spiders, so when I saw one hanging out (literally) in the shower as I started to step in, it occurred to me that my uphill battle against spiders in the house has some parallels to my efforts to maintain decent barriers within my internet and social media usage. (I would say I’m slightly less paranoid about the internet tracking.) First, autumn seems to be on its way, and the spiders are either moving in to the house, or just being more visible. We’ve dealt with a minimum of a dozen spiders in the last week. I think spiders are marvelous outside the house, which I consider to be their proper setting. I enjoy watching them scramble around in our garden space, eating pests and keeping their numbers in check. They have amazing physical characteristics and an ability to go almost anywhere. Various internet providers, online services, and social networks can also be extremely useful and have a similar, more metaphorical ability to be everywhere. I recognize that my house will never be spider-free, and my network interactions will never be surveillance-free.  On the other hand, I’m willing to go to some effort to minimize both spiders and data surrender. We try to minimize obvious cracks and food sources for arachnids in the house, and online, I pay attention to what information I’m willing to share and how I access various sites.

As I’ve read through various resources about what gets shared, stored, and tracked, I was edified to see that there wasn’t a ton of information that was entirely new to me. I use minimal profiles and background on my social media that I use for truly social purposes, like Facebook. For my more professional usage, I focus on more narrow, work-oriented background and contacts. I use multiple email addresses, including an essentially throw-away option for signing up for online services and the occasional online purchase, which I also try to minimize. I started using DuckDuckGo as my search engine a few years ago, and prefer the interface and results lists to Google. I clear history and cookies with some regularity, and the fact that my job as a librarian has me using multiple different computers in the course of a day or week, and searching for a wide variety of topics and products well outside my actual interests feels like a bit of extra camouflage as well.  

There are certainly levels of privacy protection that I’m not ready to tackle yet and don’t really feel a need to utilize. I’ve been tempted to play with Tor browsing on occasion, but I am not really interested in the attention that can also arise from that usage or that of some of the more anonymous email providers. I’m also not ready to go to a progression of burner phones or drop boxes that start to feel more like I’m playing a role in a spy thriller than managing communication. Since so many industries and jobs expect some form of an internet presence, I’d rather manage and curate one that sends a message I want rather than be completely invisible to potential colleagues and employers.